(Kafir: Literal Meaning, Theological Interpretation, and Controversy in India)
Introduction: The Controversy of “Kafir” in a Multireligious Society
In a pluralistic society like India, when the radical interpretation of Islam comes to the surface, one word often becomes the center of heated debate — “Kafir.”
On television debates, Maulanas and Muftis often claim: “Hindus are not Kafirs, because they believe in God.” They try to escape criticism by reducing this word to a mere technical term.
But the real question is: How true is this claim?
In this article, based on the Quran, Hadith, and historical contexts, we will clarify:
- What is the definition of “Kafir”?
- Who falls under this category?
- Why do Indian Muslims try to hide this reality?
The Root Meaning and Etymology of “Kafir”
Original Arabic Root
- Word: كافر (Kafir)
- Root Verb: كَفَرَ (kafara)
- Primary Meaning: “to cover, conceal, or hide”
- Literal Usage: In agriculture, covering seeds with soil
Theological Interpretation
A person who, despite knowing the truth — that is, Islam and its God (Allah) — conceals it or rejects it is called a “Kafir.”
Over time, the word came to mean “unbeliever” or “non-Muslim” — anyone who does not accept Allah and the Quran.
Summary (Table)
| Word | Root Word | Literal Meaning | Religious Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| كافر (Kafir) | ك-ف-ر (k-f-r) | To cover/conceal | One who rejects Allah and the Islamic message |
Conclusion: Based on the root word, Kafir literally means coverer/concealer. But in Islamic scripture, the meaning shifted to one who denies or rejects Allah and Islam.
Definition of Kafir in the Quran and Hadith
According to Islamic belief, anyone who does not accept Allah, Muhammad, and the Quran is a Kafir. In the Quran’s view, this includes idolaters, Jews, Christians, atheists — everyone who rejects the so-called “Islamic truth.”
Quranic Perspective
Surah Baqarah 2:98
“Whoever is an enemy to Allah, His angels, His messengers, Jibreel and Mikaeel — then Allah is an enemy to such Kafirs.”
👉 Thus, anyone who does not accept these angels is a Kafir. Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs, Jains — who don’t even know Gabriel or Michael — automatically fall under this label.
Surah al-Kafirun 109:1–2
“Say: O you Kafirs! I do not worship what you worship.”
Surah Baqarah 2:6
“As for those who disbelieve, it is the same to them whether you warn them or not — they will not believe.”
Conclusion from Verses
The Quran treats Kafirs not merely as unbelievers but as opponents and enemies. Over time, this word turned into a derogatory label used against entire communities considered outside the “true faith.”
Punishment for Kafirs in the Quran
- Surah Tawbah 9:5
“…kill the idolaters wherever you find them…”
👉 Hindus, as idol-worshippers, clearly fall into this category. - Surah Muhammad 47:8
“But as for those who disbelieve — destruction is for them, and their deeds will be in vain.” - Surah al-Anfal 8:39
“Fight them until there is no more disbelief and religion is entirely for Allah…”
👉 As long as Kafirs exist and an “Islamic state” is not established, war must continue. - Surah Nisa 4:101
“Indeed, the disbelievers are your clear enemies.”
Conclusion:
The Quran openly declares Kafirs as enemies and calls for their elimination or subjugation. Peaceful coexistence is ruled out.
Kafir in the Hadith
- Scriptural References
- Sahih Muslim 2167:
“I have been commanded to fight the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah, and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.” - Sahih Bukhari 25 (Book of Faith):
“Whoever does not accept La ilaha illallah is a Kafir, and his blood and wealth are halal.”
👉 No exceptions are made here: Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs, Jains — all are included.
- Historical & Social Impact
In Islamic empires, Kafirs were subjected to:
- Jizya tax (economic penalty on non-Muslims)
- Restricted religious freedom
- Forced conversions at times
Examples: In India, Iran, and Egypt, “Kafir” was a standard label for non-Muslim subjects. Over centuries, it became a degrading insult.
Indian Maulanas’ Arguments and Deceptions
In TV debates, Maulanas often claim:
👉 “Hindus are monotheists, therefore not Kafirs.”
Their argument: Vedas and Upanishads describe a formless God, e.g.,
“Na tasya pratima asti” (Yajurveda 32.3)
But this is misleading.
3.1 Real Meaning of “Pratima”
In Sanskrit, Pratima means representation/symbol, not the Islamic notion of “formlessness.” It conveys that God has no exact replica, not that He has no form at all.
3.2 Hindu Philosophy vs. Islam
- Hinduism accepts both saguna (with form) and nirguna (formless) aspects of God.
- Worship of Rama, Krishna, Shiva, Devi, etc. is central.
- From Islam’s perspective, this is Shirk (polytheism).
3.3 Islamic Requirements
Just believing in “One God” is not enough. To escape being labeled Kafir, one must also:
- Accept Muhammad as the final prophet
- Accept the Quran as the final revelation
- Believe in angels like Jibreel and Mikaeel
Conclusion: Kafir as a Political-Religious Label
“Kafir” is not just an Arabic religious term. It is a religio-political label used to:
- Mark unbelief and opposition
- Justify contempt and violence against non-Muslims
👉 Indian Maulanas’ claim that Hindus are not Kafirs is nothing but political deception.
Final Thoughts
Indian Muslims are repeatedly told:
- “Kafir is not an insult.”
- “Not all non-Muslims are Kafirs.”
But the Quran and Hadith are clear:
👉 Anyone who does not accept Islam is a Kafir.
Pluralism, tolerance, or “Ganga-Jamuni culture” do not shield non-Muslims. In Islamic scripture, their very existence is a problem, and their elimination or subjugation is theologically mandated.
📢 Did you find this article useful?
🙏 Support our work by clicking here.